« ZOMG! JIM AND PAM TOTALLY KISSED! | Main | Marvel vs J.C. »

September 22, 2006



Variations on a Theme

Over at ComicBloc, they want to know: "What gives retailers the LEGAL right to sell "incentive variants" at an arbitrary cost greater than the retail price?"

Then someone gets schooled:

That's why it's called a suggested manufacturer's price. The maufacturer suggests what it should cost but they can sell it for whatever they want. (the suggested price keeps the competition close though.)

Schooled with a capital "C". For Capitalism:

And here you are incorrect. Now, often it makes good business sense to adhere to MSRPs and cover prices, but there is no law requiring adhering to them. In fact, if the companies applied any pressure to us to stick to the cover prices either lower OR higher, they would be running the risk of a government investigation. I don't remember the exact details, but several years ago the record industry got in trouble over what was called "MAP" or minimum advertised price. When a new item came out, the record companies told retailers of ALL sizes that they could not advertise below a certain price. A consumer group found out of this practice and filed a class action lawsuit which resulted in fines from the federal government and a lawsuit settlement that cost the companies hundreds of millions in reimbursements. (My numbers may be a tad off, there, I'm going from memory)

As a rule, the controls and laws regarding pricing in this country exist to protect the consumer from either gouging or collusion. If every retaile in the country sat down in a room and said "We're charing $25 for Astonishing X-Men #17 variant", that would be collusion, and illegal. Gouging is only invoked, generally, in the case of raising prices on necessary items in a time of crisis. Now, you can TRY to argue in court that a comic is a necessity, but you aren't likely to get far.

Discuss this article in our forum.

Posted by YourMomsBasement at September 22, 2006 12:00 PM

Comments

Your Mom's Basement
Get your geek on.

And never wash it off.
Site Guide
Home
Message Board
The Lint Trap
52: The Blog
Email
Recent Articles
Harlan Ellison vs. Fantagraphics
And we're back....
I snorted my dad.
Ron Jeremy Gets Online Tech Show
Remake/Redesign
Someone Killing Your Childhood Again
Stan Less Media V. Stan Lee?
This is Our America
Figures It'd Be Jesus
This American Life, as Animated by Chris Ware
Past Articles
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
Search