« Unified Byrne Theory | Main | The Screw Turners »

August 23, 2006

Take your "comic consistency" and shove it up your @$$!

It was a three year old thread. Lost to the ether of the Internet...

Started in anger:

My point is that it doesnt matter if it was in the comic or not or whatever...its HOW ITS DONE.

Its the writing! Its the directing! and then its the acting!

If the writing is solid then it doesnt matter if her name is patience price or Shenequa

Plot
Story
Dialogue
character development

These make a good movie. Not some blind committment to a characters name.

Bathed in frustration:

You can´t change a characters name!
A name is part of a person.
By changing that, you change the character.
It would be the same as to make movie about Jack the Ripper and call him Ralph the Butcher
A name is part of the identity of a person.

YOU CAN´T ERASE A PERSONS IDENTITY

Painted in bad make-up:

IN batman returns michelles character had NOTHING to do with the selina kyle in the comic book. She was a freaking secretary!!! She got turned into catwoman by a bunch of freaky cats!!!

Gone. Forgotten.

And then, mere days ago... REBORN:

Yes things have changed in the Comics but that's not an excuse for Movie Maker to just make thier own crap a good Comic Booka daptation to me is one that's tries to take element form all the verisu version togather, why I Love Smallville so much.

And I hate the postcrisis Catwoman she's just an Electra Rip Off, and to the person that said Pre-Crisis Scuked let it Die, screw you Some Crisis changes would good mainly Lex Luthor but more where bad then good, and DC's had more then 2 phases In PreCrisi they had the Golden Age Silver Age the Bronze Age and some smaller unamed ages inbetween.

But the decision to bring the thread back to life was not without controversy.

Why the **** did you make an account just to bump a three year old thread?

I thought "dead meant dead"?

Posted by YourMomsBasement at August 23, 2006 09:00 AM